Trustpilot used to be a nice-to-have. Now, it's mission-critical. For prop firms, review platforms are no longer about branding or optics. They have become essential to survival.

In a space built on trust, unregulated firms cannot rely on licenses to prove credibility. That leaves one key asset: user reviews. And Trustpilot is at the top. A strong TrustScore can make or break a firm's reputation. That is why prop firms are investing heavily, hiring dedicated teams, implementing fast-response systems, and even turning to AI to protect their online image.

Review Management Becomes an Internal Department

“We hired staff just for Trustpilot,” said George Kohler, Managing Director of Alpha Capital Group. Many firms now operate internal review teams, some with multilingual agents responding to reviews across platforms within 24 hours. The goal is to solve problems quickly and, when possible, encourage clients to update their feedback.

Some firms only invite satisfied or profitable traders to leave reviews. While not technically against the rules, this can lead to a distorted view of user experience. Others take it further by purchasing fake reviews. In response, Trustpilot has removed thousands of suspicious reviews and continues to crack down on sellers offering fake feedback.

Playing by the Rules or Around Them

Since July 2024, Trustpilot has flagged over 5,000 review seller profiles. Firms such as AudaCity Capital and Blue Guardian have seen large volumes of reviews removed. When that happens, the impact is immediate. A TrustScore can drop from Excellent to Bad almost overnight.

Despite the risks, some companies still choose shortcuts, hoping to build trust quickly. But reputation manipulation rarely works long term. Traders talk, online communities notice, and once credibility is damaged, it is difficult to recover.

Turning Reviews into Recovery

Some prop firms are now focusing on building trust through service, not just scores. Hola Prime, which recently experienced a significant drop in its Trustpilot review count following a platform audit, has shifted its strategy toward faster service and greater transparency. The firm now offers one-hour payouts, aiming to rebuild confidence through speed, consistency, and direct support.

Alternatives Are Emerging

Some prop firms are exploring industry-specific platforms such as PropFirmMatch and Forex Peace Army. These sites focus on verified trader experiences, track payout reliability, and respond more directly to fake reviews. While smaller in scale, they offer a more targeted and transparent approach to feedback.

Even so, Trustpilot remains the most widely recognized review site in the trading industry. A firm’s TrustScore often appears first in search engine results and strongly influences trader decisions.

Conclusion: Reviews Are the New Compliance

For prop firms operating without regulatory oversight, perception becomes reality. Managing a trustworthy online presence is not just a marketing effort. It is a key part of business strategy. And while shortcuts might offer temporary gains, transparency and responsiveness are what build real credibility in the long run.

‍